Clone Design vs Background Removal in POD: Key Differences for T-Shirt Sellers
Contents
If you’re a T-shirt seller in the Print-on-Demand (POD) space—especially on Amazon Merch, Etsy, or Shopify—you’ve probably heard the terms “clone design” and “background removal” thrown around. But are they the same thing? And more importantly, what should you actually be doing to grow your Merch by Amazon business safely?
Let’s clear up the confusion and help you understand how to apply each method without risking your account.
🧠 The 3 Main Types of POD Design
🔹 Design Type 1: Clone Design
Recreate a design exactly like an existing one.
-
Challenge: Matching it perfectly depends on your ability to find similar fonts, graphics, and textures.
-
Caution: If you clone from Amazon and upload back to Amazon, that’s a huge risk.
Design Type 2: Redesign
Take inspiration from an existing design but change the layout, style, and elements while keeping the same core message.
-
More freedom to customize and stay unique
-
A great method to follow Amazon’s content policy and still chase trends
🔹 Design Type 3: New Design
Start from scratch with just a text prompt or idea. Use your own style, choose your own elements, and create something original.
-
Most safe and sustainable strategy
-
Ideal for building your own POD brand
🧩 Redesign vs Clone Design: What's the Real Difference?
🔁 Clone Design
Clone design means recreating a design as closely as possible to the original. You study the layout, fonts, illustrations, and message—and try to rebuild it using similar resources.
✅ Pros:
-
Fast way to follow trends
-
Gives you a tested structure or idea to base your version on
❌ Cons:
-
High risk if you clone from Amazon or any platform and upload back to Amazon
-
May violate copyright if too similar
-
Can be reported by other sellers (even from Etsy or Redbubble!)
Example: You see a best-selling shirt that says “Goat Mama” with a cute cartoon goat and rainbow. You rebuild it with a similar font, similar goat, and layout. That’s a clone design — and risky if it’s too close to the original.
🎨 Redesign
Redesign means using a concept or theme as inspiration, but you change the style, composition, or elements to create a new visual interpretation of the idea.
You’re keeping the spirit of the message but expressing it in your own way.
✅ Pros:
-
Much safer for Amazon Merch
-
Adds your own creativity and style
-
Easier to build your brand identity
-
Lower chance of takedown/report
❌ Cons:
-
Requires more creativity and some design skill
-
You still need to check for trademarks (e.g. don’t use trademarked phrases!)
Example: You take the “Goat Mama” idea and redesign it as “Proud Goat Lady” with a retro font, floral background, and a watercolor goat — this is a safe and original redesign.
🔑 Key Difference:
| Feature | Clone Design | Redesign |
|---|---|---|
|
Main Goal |
Rebuild the same look |
Express the same idea in a new visual style
|
|
Risk Level |
⚠️ High (if too similar) |
✅ Low (if creative and original)
|
|
Creativity Needed |
Low to Medium |
Medium to High
|
|
Safe for Amazon Merch |
❌ Risky if copied from Amazon or Etsy |
✅ Safe when done right
|
✅ What Should You Do for Amazon Merch?
Amazon has strict content guidelines, and many accounts are banned for copyright violations. Here’s the smart breakdown:
❌ Don’t Clone from Amazon for Amazon — Or from Etsy Either!
A common mistake many sellers make is thinking,
“I’ll just spy on Etsy, clone a trending design, and upload it to Amazon Merch.”
At first, it might seem like a clever shortcut. But here’s the reality:
-
🔒 Amazon’s copyright detection systems are strong — they scan for visual similarities in text, images, and layouts.
-
⚠️ Some sellers get their Amazon account closed without knowing why. They later find out that their design was reported for copyright violation — not by Amazon, but by another seller who saw their design copied.
Even if you clone from Etsy or another platform, remember:
All platforms — Amazon, Etsy, Redbubble, etc. — are indexed on Google Images.
Competitors can search their designs, find your copied version on Amazon, and report you. Amazon takes these reports seriously and will close your account without warning.
💥 So no matter the source, direct cloning is risky. Avoid it at all costs.
-
Copyright detection systems are strong
-
Avoid direct copies
✅ Do Redesigns from Amazon Trends
-
See what sells (phrases, niches, layout)
-
Change fonts, artwork, colors, layout
-
Add your own spin (this keeps you safe)
Example: Change a trending shirt that says “Goat Mama” with a cartoon goat into “Proud Goat Lady” with a hand-drawn goat and rustic font.
✅ Use Background Removal for Legal Assets
-
Remove backgrounds from art you legally licensed (like from Creative Fabrica)
-
Combine with your own text or other assets
-
Make the final design yours
✅✅ Best Strategy: Make New Designs
-
Use trending niches or funny phrases
-
Create original graphics or combine safe elements
-
Stand out with custom ideas
Example: Create a shirt with “Fluff Around and Find Out” using your own illustrated cat and vintage font. Totally original = no risk!
💼 Hiring a Designer? Be Smart
If you don’t have time or tools to design, outsourcing can help. But make sure to:
-
Explain your vision clearly
-
Ask for editable files (PSD, AI, SVG)
-
Confirm they don’t steal or copy
-
Choose designers experienced with Amazon POD
🎯 Final Thoughts
Clone design and background removal are two very different tools. For Amazon Merch:
-
❌ Avoid direct cloning
-
✅ Redesign wisely
-
✅ Use background removal for safe editing
-
✅✅ Create new designs for long-term success
-
✍️ Redesigns from trending ideas
-
🎨 Brand new POD designs made from scratch
Let us help you grow your Amazon Merch business with safe, scalable, and trend-aware design services.
• Managing list 200 Merch tier 500 generating sale.
• Niche research expert.
• Export entrepreneur & Trader cryptocurrency.
- Clone Design vs Background Removal in POD: Key Differences for T-Shirt Sellers - June 24, 2025
- Mother’s Day & Father’s Day 2025 - April 17, 2025
- Understand How Amazon Merch Sends Money to Payment Platforms - February 21, 2025
